Ɛnnɛ yɛreka tebea a ɛyɛ basabasa, ɛrekɔ ntɛmntɛm wɔ Anthropic, Claude yɛfo a mprempren ohu ne ho wɔ mmara mu ɔko a ɛyɛ abofono yiye mu ne Pentagon no ho asɛm.
Akyi ne akyi no yɛ nea emu yɛ den, nanso ɛde besi nna kakraa bi a atwam ni no, na Pentagon abu Anthropic sɛ asiane wɔ nneɛma a wɔde ma mu, na Anthropic de asɛm akɔdan mmaranimfo de akasa atia saa din no, na wɔaka sɛ aban no abu ne hokwan ahorow a ɛwɔ Nsakrae a Edi Kan ne Anum mu no so denam “ɔhwehwɛ a ɔhwehwɛ sɛ ɔbɛsɛe sikasɛm mu mfaso a wiase ankorankoro nnwumakuw a ɛrenya nkɔso ntɛmntɛm no mu biako de aba no so.” Metumi aka akyerɛ wo seesei ara: Yɛrebɛka saa asɛm no mu twitwa ne nsakraeɛ ho asɛm wɔ The Verge ne ha wɔ Decoder wɔ asram a ɛreba no mu.
Nanso ɛnnɛ na mepɛ sɛ megye bere kakra na metutu fam ankasa wɔ ha ankasa wɔ ade biako a ɛho hia yiye wɔ tebea yi mu a ennyaa adwene a ɛdɔɔso bere a eyi ayɛ spiraled out of control: sɛnea United States aban no yɛ surveillance, mmara kwan so tumi a ɛma kwan ma saa surveillance no ba, ne nea enti a Anthropic nni ahotoso wɔ aban no mu sɛ ɛbɛka sɛ wobedi mmara no akyi bere a ɛfa AI a wɔde bedi dwuma de ayɛ surveillance kɛse mpo no.
Verge subscribers, mma wo werɛ mmfi sɛ wobɛnya kwan soronko akɔ Decoder a ad-free so wɔ baabiara a wobɛnya wo podcasts. Fa w’ani kyerɛ ha. Ɛnyɛ obi a ɔkyerɛw ne din? Wubetumi akyerɛw wo din wɔ ha.
Me ahɔhoɔ nnɛ ne Mike Masnick, a ɔhyehyɛɛ Techdirt, tech nhyehyɛeɛ wɛbsaet a ɛyɛ papa na ɛkɔ so kyɛ no. Mike akyerɛw aban a ɛboro so, kokoam nsɛm wɔ dijitaal bere yi mu, ne nsɛmti afoforo a ɛfa ho mfe du du pii ni. Ɔyɛ ɔbenfoɔ wɔ sɛdeɛ intanɛt ne surveillance state no anyin wɔ akwan a ɛka bom so.
Woahu, nea mmara no ka sɛ aban no betumi ayɛ bere a ɛfa yɛn a wɔbɛhwɛ yɛn so no wɔ hɔ, na afei nea aban no pɛ sɛ ɛyɛ. Na nea ɛho hia sen biara no, nea aban no ka sɛ mmara no se ebetumi ayɛ wɔ hɔ, a mpɛn pii no ɛne nea obiara a ɔte ase a ɔkenkan mmara no ara kwa besusuw no bɔ abira pɛpɛɛpɛ.
You’ll hear Mike explain in great detail here in this episode sɛ yɛrentumi — na ɛnsɛ sɛ — yɛfa U.S. aban no wɔ n’asɛm mu bere a ɛfa surveillance ho no. There’s just too much history of government lawyers twisting the interpretations of simple words like “target” to expand surveillance in complicated ways — akwan a ɛtaa de dadwen ba mmara kwan so akuw nkutoo mu, na ɛbɔ bere a akyinnyegye akɛse te sɛ whistleblower Ed Snowden NSA adiyi atitiriw bɛboro mfe du a atwam ni no wɔ hɔ nkutoo.
Nanso biribiara nni hɔ a ɛyɛ anifere anaasɛ ɛyɛ nwonwa wɔ nhyehyɛe a wɔyɛ ho wɔ Trump bere so — na enti yɛne Anthropic no, yɛregye akyinnye denneennen, baguam yiye a ɛfa mfiridwuma ne nhwehwɛmu ho wɔ bere ankasa mu, wɔ intanɛt so, wɔ blog nsɛm ne X rants mu, ne nsɛm ho amanneɛbɔfo nhyiam nnyigyei-ka ho. There’s positives and negatives to that, nanso sɛ ntease bɛba ne nyinaa mu a, ɛsɛ sɛ wuhu abakɔsɛm no ankasa.
Ɛno ne nea me ne Mike sii gyinae sɛ yɛbɛkyerɛkyerɛ mu wɔ saa adeyɛ yi mu — ɛmfa ho sɛnea w’adwene wɔ AI ne aban ho no, saa adeyɛ yi bɛma ada adi pefee sɛ afã abien no nyinaa ama ɔman a ɛhwɛ nneɛma so no ayɛ kɛse na ayɛ kɛse bere kɔ so. Seesei, yɛwɔ ntrɛwmu kɛse a ɛsen biara a yɛde besi nnɛ bere a ɛfa AI ho no ho.
Okay: Techdirt a ɔhyehyɛɛ ne CEO Mike Masnick wɔ Anthropic, Pentagon, ne AI nhwehwɛmu ho. Ɛha na yɛrekɔ.
Wɔayɛ nsɛmbisa yi mu nsakraeɛ kakra sɛdeɛ ɛbɛyɛ a ɛbɛyɛ tenten na emu ada hɔ.
Mike Masnick, wo ne Techdirt a ɔhyehyɛɛ ne CEO. Yɛma wo akwaaba ba Decoder.
M’ani agye sɛ mewɔ ha.
M’ani agye sɛ manya wo wɔ so. Na mereka kɛkɛ sɛ ɛyɛ me nwonwa sɛ wo nkɔɔ show no mu da. Me ne wo akyerɛw na yɛakyerɛw nsɛm atwa yɛn ho yɛn ho ho ahyia akyɛ. The Verge policy coverage pii de ɛka bi wɔ nea woayɛ wɔ Techdirt na afei nea ɛrekɔ so wɔ Anthropic no yɛ den yiye, nanso ɛbɔ themes pii a woakata so bere tenten saa. M’ani agye sɛ awiei koraa no woaba ha.
Ɛyɛ asɛmti bi basabasa a ɛyɛ den, nanso m’ani agye sɛ meretutu mu.
Nea mepɛ sɛ me ne mo de m’adwene si so no nyɛ nsɛm a ɛfa sɛ ebia Anthropic ne aban no bɛhyɛ apam ase anaasɛ OpenAI benya saa apam no. Mmom, mewɔ ahotoso sɛ bere a yɛbɛkyere eyi ne bere a nkurɔfo betie no ntam no, tweet pii bɛba na nneɛma pii bɛyɛ soronko sen sɛnea na ɛte kan no.
Nea mepɛ sɛ mede m’adwene si so ne nkyerɛwde kɔkɔɔ abien a Anthropic de ato hɔ ankasa no mu biako pɛ. Wɔn mu biako neakode a ɛde ne ho, a ɛyɛ n’ankasa nsɛnnennen dodow. Mmara a ɛwɔ hɔ no refi ase kakra sɛ ebia akode no wɔ hɔ mpo anaasɛ Russia de adi dwuma dedaw wɔ Ukraine Ko no mu anaasɛ enni hɔ.
Adwene pii wɔ ha a mepɛ sɛ mede saa asɛm no to nkyɛn kɛkɛ efisɛ misusuw sɛ ɛno bɛba wɔ adwene kɛse mu ne nyinaa wɔ n’ankasa nhyehyɛe so. Ntrɛwmu kɔkɔɔ foforo a mepɛ sɛ mede bere pii yɛ ne sɛ wɔbɛhwɛ nnipa pii so. Na mmara pii wɔ ha a ɛfa mass surveillance ho. Abakɔsɛm pii wɔ hɔ, abakɔsɛm a akyinnyegye wom pii. Edward Snowden suban nyinaa wɔ hɔ esiane akyinnyegye ahorow a ɛfa nnipadɔm a wɔhwɛ wɔn so nti.
Ne nyinaa ba fam —misusuw sɛ wo na wode eyi too hɔ —Ɔman Ahobammɔ Dwumadibea (NSA), a ɛyɛ Department of Defense no fã, a ɛsɛ sɛ yɛfrɛ no Department of War mprempren esiane biribi nti.
[Ɔserew] Ɛnsɛ sɛ yɛyɛ biribiara.
[Ɔserew] Yɛnnyɛ saa. Ɛno yɛ nokware wɔ Amerika ha. Ɛho nhia sɛ yɛyɛ biribiara. Nanso titiriw no, NSA asan akyerɛkyerɛ nea nsɛmfua pii kyerɛ wɔ kasa mu Borɔfo kasa mu ma ɛkyerɛ sɛ, “Yɛbɛtumi ayɛ nhwehwɛmu kɛkɛ.” Na afei mpɛn pii no aniwusɛm bi ba bere a nkurɔfo hu sɛ wɔreyɛ surveillance kɛkɛ no. Enti fa asɛnka agua no si hɔ kɛkɛ, na mempɛ sɛ mɛsan akɔ wo akyi wɔ kwan no nyinaa so, nanso ɛyɛ bere pii a saa nhwɛso yi asan ayɛ bio.
Egyina sɛnea wopɛ sɛ wokɔ mu no so, nanso ɛda adi sɛ nea ɛyɛ tiawa no wɔ 9/11 akyi wiase no mu, U.S. na ɛhyɛɛ Ɔman Ho Dɔ Mmara no, a na ɛwɔ tumi bi ma aban no sɛ ɛde ne ho bɛhyɛ nhwehwɛmu mu, a na ɛsɛ sɛ ɛyɛ nea wɔde bɛbɔ yɛn ho ban afi daakye amumɔyɛfo ahunahuna ho. Bere kɔɔ so no, wɔkyerɛɛ ɛno ase wɔ akwan a ɛyɛ anigye so na na anohyeto ahorow bi wɔ saa asɛm no ho. Na yɛwɔ FISA asɛnnibea nso, a ɛyɛ asɛnnibea titiriw a wɔkyerɛ sɛ ɛhwɛ amansɛmdifo kuw no ne wɔn dwumadi ahorow mu, nanso efi tete no ayɛ asɛnnibea a ɛwɔ ɔfã biako. Ɔfã biako pɛ na wonya kwan de wɔn asɛm no kɔdan saa asɛnnibea no na wɔyɛ ne nyinaa wɔ kokoam.
Nneɛma pii wɔ hɔ a na wonnim. Na afei na afã foforo biako wɔ eyi nyinaa mu, a ɛkɔ akyiri kodu Ronald Reagan so, a ɛyɛ Executive Order 12333, a wɔkyerɛ sɛ ɛfa ɔkwan no ho mmara a wɔde besi hɔ ama amanneɛbɔ a wɔboaboa ano ho.
Enti wowɔ saa mmara abiɛsa yi —wiɛ, mmara kakraa bi —ne aban ahyɛde a ɛkyerɛ ɔmanfo, afã horow a wubetumi akenkan no, ɛte sɛ nea ɛka nsɛm bi fa nea yɛn aban ne NSA titiriw betumi ayɛ wɔ hwɛ a wɔhwɛ so no ho. Sɛ yɛde Borɔfo nsɛm asekyerɛ nhoma a ɛnyɛ den kenkan, a ebia me ne wo su na yɛte ase a, anka yɛbɛba abɛba abɛka gyidi bi a ɛne sɛ na tumi a NSA wɔ sɛ wɔhwɛ Amerikafo so no sua koraa, nokwarem no, akodu baabi a ɛsɛ sɛ wɔyɛ saa, sɛ wohu sɛ wɔrehwɛ U.S. nipa bi so a, sɛ ɛsɛ sɛ wogyae ntɛm ara na wosu fĩ na wɔpopa data no ne nneɛma afoforo yi nyinaa.
Na nsɛm bi wɔ hɔ bere tiaa bi sɛ ɛno nsi ankasa na na nsɛm bi nso wɔ hɔ na ne titiriw no, Mmarahyɛ Bagua no muni Ron Wyden de nne kɛse kaa sɛ ɔbɛkɔ Mmarahyɛ Bagua no fam na waka sɛ, “Biribi nyɛ yiye wɔ ha na mintumi nka nea ɛyɛ pɛpɛɛpɛ nkyerɛ mo,” anaasɛ wɔ asɛm a wotie mu no na obebisa amansɛmdifo sɛ, “So woreboaboa Amerikafo ho nsɛm pii ano anaasɛ worenboaboa nsɛm pii ano?”
Ná saa mpanyimfo no bɛdan wɔn ho anaasɛ wɔ tebea horow bi mu no, na wɔadi atoro koraa. Megye di sɛ ɛyɛ asɛm baako a wɔdii wɔ afe 2012 mu a James Clapper a na ɔyɛ Ɔman Amanneɛbɔ sohwɛfoɔ saa berɛ no, baabi a wɔbisabisaa no tẽẽ wɔ saa asɛm yi ho. Na ɔkae titiriw sɛ, “Dabi, yɛnboaboa Amerikafo ho nsɛm ano.” Ɛno yɛ nea ɛkanyan Ed Snowden ma ɔde data no puei no fã kɛse, amanneɛbɔ ahorow a ɛkyerɛ sɛ ɔde too gua maa Glenn Greenwald ne Barton Gellman ne Laura Poitras nso. Efi ne nyinaa mu no, nea yefii ase hui ne sɛ NSA wɔ n’ankasa nsɛm asekyerɛ nhoma a ɛyɛ soronko kakra wɔ nsɛm asekyerɛ nhoma a me ne wo de di dwuma no ho, sɛnea ɛbɛyɛ a wobetumi akyerɛ nsɛmfua ase wɔ akwan horow so a ɛsono Engiresi kasa mu ntease a ɛda adi pefee a ɛwɔ mu, a nsɛmfua te sɛ “target” a ɛte sɛ asɛmfua titiriw ka ho. Nteaseɛ a ɛtrɛ wɔ deɛ yei yɛ ho ne sɛ, wɔ nsusuiɛ mu no, ɛsɛ sɛ wɔde wɔn ani si nnipa a wɔnyɛ U.S. nnipa nko ara so, mesusu sɛ ɛyɛ kasasin no.
Nanso ɔkwan a na wɔafa so akyerɛ ase bere tenten ne sɛ biribiara a ɛka saa onipa no ho asɛm, biribiara a ɛfa ɔnanani bi ho no, mprempren ɛyɛ agoru a ɛfata, sɛ ɛno ne nkitahodi ahorow a aU.S. nipa. Enti sɛ me ne wo de text message kɔma yɛn ho yɛn ho na yɛka ɔnanani bi ho asɛm a, afei de ɛno yɛ fair game ma NSA sɛ wɔbɛboaboa ano na wɔakora so na wɔde asie.
Eyi fã a ɛto so abien wɔ hɔ. Mekaa Executive Order 12333 a edi kan a efi Ronald Reagan hɔ, a, bere a mfiridwuma no sesae bere kɔɔ so na intanɛt no nyin no, wɔ ɔkwan a etu mpɔn so no, ɛmaa NSA kwan ma wɔde wɔn ho hyɛɛ amannɔne nkitahodi mu, nanso na nkitahodi biara a ebia ɛmaa U.S. kɔɔ kwan so kɔɔ baabi ka ho. Enti sɛ merekyerɛw wo text na nkra bi fii me hɔ wɔ California denam fiber optic cable a ɛbaa sɛ efi US so a, NSA betumi de tap ahyɛ ɔfã no mu bere a ɛwɔ US akyi no na wɔaboaboa saa nsɛm no ano, sɛ mpo na ɛrekɔ wo nkyɛn wɔ US mu ara kwa a.
Afei NSA betumi de saa nsɛm no asie sɛ ɛyɛ U.S. nnipa mpo a, na wobetumi ayɛ nhwehwɛmu pɔtee bi wɔ saa asɛm no ho akyiri yi, a ɛtɔ mmere bi a wɔfrɛ no “akyi pon mu nhwehwɛmu.” Wɔboaboaa saa nsɛm yi ano a yegye di sɛ na ɛnsɛ sɛ wɔboaboa ano wɔ nea edi kan no mu, nanso wobetumi de asie. Na wɔhyɛɛ bɔ, wɔkaa ntam pinky, sɛ wɔde bɛto kokoam, nanso sɛ wɔyɛ hwehwɛ na wohu sɛ wo anaa me kaa ɔnanani bi ho asɛm a, ɛnde mpofirim ara na ɛyɛ fair game ma wɔn sɛ wɔde bɛyɛ nea wɔpɛ biara.
Sɛ yɛka ne nyinaa bom a, ɛno adan wiase a ne titiriw no, aban a ɛwɔ ɔman no mu no betumi aboaboa nsɛm biara a ɛba sɛ ɛka U.S. akyi ano. Sɛ ɛyɛ U.S. nnipa baanu ntam koraa mpo a, sɛ wɔka obi a ɔnyɛ U.S. nipa ho asɛm anaasɛ wɔkyerɛ mpo a, mpofirim ara ɛyɛ agoru a ɛfata sɛ wɔboaboa ano. Na ɛno mu na yɛanya nea ɛte sɛ nea ɛyɛ ɔkwan bi a wɔfa so hwɛ U.S. nnipa pii so denam NSA bi a ɛka na ɛka wɔ baguam sɛ wɔnsrasra U.S. nnipa so.
Ɛyɛɛ dɛn na yeduu saa beae yi? Eyi yɛ nkokoaa anammɔn a ɛkɔ soro pii. Wokaa James Clapper ho asɛm wɔ afe 2012 mu, ɛno ne Obama aban no. Wokaa Ronald Reagan ho asɛm, ɛno ne 1980 mfeɛ no. Yɛrefa Democrats ne Republicans mu wɔ ha.
Ɔko a wɔde ko tia ehu no sii wɔ George W. Bush nniso no mu, na 9/11 ne Ɔman Ho Dɔ Mmara no sii wɔ George W. Bush nniso no mu. Nneɛma bɔne pii wɔ hɔ a ɛkɔ so nkakrankakra wɔ akuw abien no nyinaa titrani ase, wɔ akuw abien no nyinaa nhyiam horow ase. Ɛyɛɛ dɛn na eyi bae?
Ɔkwan a ɛyɛ mmerɛw sen biara ne sɛ obiara, na akyinnye biara nni ho sɛ ɔmampanyin biara, mpɛ sɛ ɔyɛ ɔmampanyin wɔ bere a amumɔyɛfo ntua kɛse bi wɔ hɔ no mu, efisɛ ɛno ma wɔyɛ wɔn ho sɛ wɔyɛ bɔne. Ɛda adi sɛ wɔpɛ sɛ wɔbɔ Amerikafo nso ho ban, ɛnte saa? Ɛno yɛ wɔn adwuma no fã. Sɛ wowɔ amansɛmdifo kuw bi a ne titiriw no wɔreyɛ adwuma wɔ sum mu efisɛ ɛno ne nea amansɛmdifo akuw yɛ na wɔkɔ so ba wo nkyɛn na wɔka sɛ, “Hey, sɛ yebetumi anya saa nsɛm yi ara kwa a, anka ɛbɛboa ankasa wɔ amumɔyɛfo ntua a yebesiw ano no mu.”
Ebia nsɛm bi wɔ hɔ a ɛyɛ nokware, sɛ amansɛmdifo kuw no tumi de saa nsɛm yi di dwuma wɔ ɔkwan a ɛyɛ adwuma yiye so. Nanso yɛyɛ nso, wɔ nsusuwii mu, mmara fekuw a yɛwɔ U.S. Amanyɔ Mmara a ɛsɛ sɛ yedi so. Nanso ɛno maa kwan ma nokwasɛm a ɛyɛ sɛ nniso akyi nniso, bio, Republican ne Democrat, na wɔwɔ mmaranimfo a wɔyɛ anifere kɛse na wɔbɛhwɛ mu na wɔaka sɛ, “Wiɛ, sɛ yɛyɛ gyinabea bi wɔ saa kwan yi so anaasɛ yɛka eyi ase anaasɛ yɛkyerɛ eyi ase a, saa kwan no so no yebetumi anya nea yɛpɛ na yɛammu mmara no so wɔ mfiridwuma mu anaasɛ yɛrento Nsakrae a Ɛto so Anan no so wɔ mfiridwuma mu.”
Na adwene no yɛ bere nyinaa sɛ, “Yɛbɛtumi ayɛ sɛ yɛbɛbɔ mmara no anaasɛ yɛbɛbɔ yɛn nkyerɛaseɛ a yɛde ma mmara no na obiara renhunu yei ankasa da, anaasɛ obiara a ɔdwene ho no renhunu yei ankasa da, na ɛno nti yɛbɛnya yɛn ho afiri mu.”
Nneɛma abien wɔ hɔ a ɛhuruw ba me so ankasa. Baako, me ne wo nyinaa kenkan asɛnnibea gyinaesi pii — asɛnnibea a wɔde asɛm kɔdan no gyinaesi ne Asɛnnibea Kunini no gyinaesi. Na ɔko bi wɔ yɛn Asɛnnibea Kunini no mu wɔ sɛnea yɛbɛkyerɛ nsɛmfua a ɛwɔ yɛn mmara ne yɛn mmara mu no ase ankasa ho.
I won’t get too far into it, nanso mɛka sɛ generally adwene a ɛne sɛ ɛsɛ sɛ wokenkan nsɛmfua a ɛwɔ kratafa no so kɛkɛ na woyɛ nea wɔka no ne mmara mu nkyerɛase a ɛyɛ den titiriw wɔ United States. Benkum anaa nifa, wɔn baanu nyinaa ka. Wɔgye akyinnye wɔ nea ɛno kyerɛ ankasa ho nsɛm pa bi a ɛyɛ ahintasɛm yiye ho. Nanso sɛ ɛsɛ sɛ wutumi kenkan nsɛmfua yi ara kwa na woyɛ nea wɔka no, ɛno nyɛ nea ɛfata, ɛnte saa?
Yɛ’asi fam anyɛ yiye koraa no saa nea edi kan a wobɛfa so no sofrɛ no nkyerɛwee ho nimdeɛ. Ɔkwan bɛn so na nniso abien no nyinaa mmaranimfo tumi twe wɔn ho fi ɔkwan titiriw a wɔfa so si mmara kwan so gyinae wɔ yɛn man yi mu no ho? Atemmufo a wɔwɔ afã abien no nyinaa gye tom sɛ anyɛ yiye koraa no, ɛno ne ade a edi kan.
Me yam a anka minim mmuae no pɔtee, nanso misusuw sɛ ɛyɛ nsusuwii a ɛkanyan, ɛnte saa? Sɛ́ mmaranimfo no, wowɔ hɔ sɛ wobɛbɔ w’asɛm no ho ban na nkonimdi — sɛ wubetumi afrɛ no nkonimdi a — yɛn mmara nhyehyɛe no taa gyina tebea a ɛyɛ ɔsɔretia a wowɔ a wowɔ afã horow a wogye akyinnye wɔ saa nneɛma yi ho so, baabi a ɔtemmufo no dwumadi ne sɛ ɔbɛtew ne ho na wahu ɔfã a ɛteɛ ankasa.
Ɔhaw baako a ɛwɔ intelligence community ne setup a ɛwɔ mu ne sɛ wo nni saa adversarial situation no. Ɛno ma ɛyɛ mmerɛw ma ɔfã biako sɛ wobebu akyinnyegye a wɔregye no bem efisɛ obiara npia no n’akyi ankasa. Wode ɛno ka ho ne suro a ɛwɔ hɔ nyinaa sɛ amumɔyɛfo ntua foforo, biribiara a ɛfa ɔman ahobammɔ ho, ne mpo bere a wowɔ tebea horow a wowɔ FISA asɛnnibea no — mekyerɛ sɛ na FISA asɛnnibea no agye din kakra sɛ ɛyɛ rɔba stamp wɔ ɔkwan a etu mpɔn so mfe pii.
Me werɛ fi dodow pɔtee no, nanso na ɛyɛ biribi te sɛ akwammisa a ɛkɔɔ FISA asɛnnibea sɛ wɔmma kwan ma wɔhwɛ tebea horow bi so no mu bɛboro ɔha biara mu nkyem 99, na ɛnyɛ den sɛ yɛbɛka sɛ ɛda adi sɛ ɔha biara mu nkyem 99 dɔɔso dodo. Ɛda adi sɛ wɔn a wɔde claims reba asɛnnibea no, wɔrepaw na wɔrepaw. Wɔnnyɛ, wɔ fã kɛse no ara mu no, wɔde nsɛm a ɛyɛ kraman koraa reba. Nanso sɛ saa ɔsɔretia afã no nni hɔ na nnipa kuw bi a wɔwɔ nkannyan a emu yɛ den yiye a wosusuw sɛ, “Ɛsɛ sɛ yɛyɛ eyi,” anaasɛ nniso bi reka akyerɛ wɔn sɛ, “Ɛsɛ sɛ yɛyɛ eyi” nni hɔ a, wɔbɛhwehwɛ akwan a wɔbɛfa so ayɛ. Na ɛhɔ na bere kɔ so no, wubewie.
So obi wɔ hɔ a ɔde ne ho ahyɛ saa adeyɛ yi mu a wanyane na waka akyerɛ ne ho pɛn sɛ, “Abarimaa, yɛatumi asan akyerɛkyerɛ asɛmfua ‘botae’ mu ma akyerɛ biribiara a yɛpɛ”?
[Ɔserew] Ɛda adi sɛ na wowɔ Ed Snowden, a ɔde nkrataa pii guu mu. Na wowɔ John Napier Tye, a ɔkyerɛw asɛm bi maa The Washington Post wɔ afe 2014 mu, a ɛdaa nkyerɛaseɛ a ɛwɔ Executive Order 12333 mu adi, na ɔkaa sɛ ɛno ne asɛm ankasa a ɛsɛ sɛ yɛhwɛ so. Wowɔ nnipa afoforo a wɔaka saa nneɛma yi ho asɛm, nanso fã kɛse no ara no, wɔtɔ nnipa a wɔde wɔn ho hyɛ adwumayɛ mu wɔ adwumayɛkuw no mu wɔ amansɛmdifo kuw nneɛma ho no mu kɔ amansɛmdifo kuw no adwene mu, a ɛne sɛ botae titiriw ne sɛ wɔbɛbɔ ɔman no ho ban afi biribi bɔne bi ho. Ɔkwan a eye sen biara a wobɛfa so ayɛ saa ne sɛ wubenya nsɛm pii sɛnea wubetumi.
Ɛnyɛ den sɛ wobɛnya tema ama akyinnyegye a ɛne sɛ, yiw, sɛ wonya nsɛm pii a, ebia ɛbɛma wɔatumi akyere biribi ntɛm anaasɛ wɔanya biribi a ɛho hia, nanso, biako, ebia ɛnyɛ nokware. Ebia nsɛm pii a wubenya no nye te sɛ nsɛm kakraa bi efisɛ ɛtaa tumi de nsɛm a mfaso wɔ so ankasa, nsɛm a wuhia ankasa na ama woahu biribi no asie.
Nanso nso, yɛwɔ U..S. Constitution in the first place na yɛwɔ nteaseɛ a enti, wɔ theory mu no, ɛnsɛ sɛ yɛma kwan ma mass surveillance a ɛnyɛ probable cause. Sɛ́ ɔman a wogye mmara nniso di no, ɛsɛ sɛ yetumi tra ase ma ɛne saa nneɛma no hyia, na sɛ saa nneɛma yi nyinaa si wɔ sum mu a, wobɛpɛ sɛ w’ani bɛyera saa.
Eyi de me ba Anthropic so. Anthropic yɛ adwumakuw a wɔyɛ adwuma titiriw. Wɔn ho akokwaw wɔ aban mu, wɔakyekye saa ntini no, nnipa a wonim saa nneɛma yi bi yiye ankasa na wɔyɛ adwumayɛfo. Ɛda adi sɛ wɔhwɛɛ Pete Hegseth sɛ, “Yɛpɛ sɛ wɔde di dwuma wɔ mmara kwan so nyinaa,” na wɔkɔɔ nkyerɛase ahorow abien kɔɔ fam na wɔkae sɛ, “Wiɛ, wo gyidi ankasa ne sɛ saa nsɛmfua yi nkyerɛ nea wɔka sɛ ɛkyerɛ wɔ wɔn anim. Enti ‘mmara kwan so dwumadie nyinaa’ sõ dodo, na yɛpɛ sɛ yɛde awɛmfoɔ bi si hɔ titire twa nnipadɔm a wɔbɛhwɛ wɔn so.”
Bio, I’m going to bracket out autonomous weapons, which was the other red line, but particularly on mass surveillance, Dario Amodei wɔ abɔnten hɔ ka sɛ, "Yɛbɛtumi ayɛ pii dodo. Eyi yɛ asiane dodo. Eyi yɛ Fourth Amendment violation."
Nhyɛsoɔ a ɛwɔ hɔ ne sɛ “woreka sɛ wobɛdi saa mmara a ɛka asɛm baako yi so na afei, wɔ saa berɛ yi nyinaa akyi no, wɔkyerɛ biribi soronko koraa na yɛmpɛ sɛ yɛbɛyɛ saa asɛm no fã kɛkɛ.” Ɛno neko. Mepɛ sɛ mede ɛno toto Sam Altman ho ara kwa, a ɔde ne ho hyɛ mu ka sɛ, “Yɛbɛyɛ mmara kwan so dwumadie nyinaa,” na afei ɔde nkrasɛm tenten yi to hɔ a ɛte sɛ, “Mmara a yɛbɛdi so nyinaa nie.”
Ɛte sɛ nea na Altman nnim sɛnea NSA asan akyerɛ saa nneɛma yi ase na ɔkwan bi so no, wɔfaa no kɔɔ kar mu. Na he’s since started walking it back — mpo bere a yɛrekyere agu hama so no, mewɔ awerɛhyem sɛ tweets pii wɔ hɔ na obiara gyinabea asesa. Nanso Altman akɔ so anantew akɔ akyi brɛoo, nanso ɛte sɛ nea OpenAI nyaa hama sɛ wɔbɛkenkan mmara ahorow no wɔ wɔn anim na wɔagye nea wɔkae no adi. So saa na wo nkyerɛase a wode ma wɔ nsɛm a esisi ho nso?
Nneɛma abien na ebetumi aba, na ɛno ne emu biako. Biako ne sɛ wɔbɔɔ no wɔ ɔkwan koro no ara so sɛnea ɔmanfo bɔɔ no mfe pii no. Nsusuwii foforo, na minni adwene biara sɛ eyinom mu biako yɛ nokware, ne sɛ ɔno anaa mmaranimfo bi a wɔwɔ OpenAI — a misusuw sɛ wɔn ho akokwaw yiye na wɔwɔ nimdeɛ kɛse — nim eyi, nanso wosusuwii sɛ wobetumi adi agoru koro no ara a NSA dii mfe du du kakraa bi no, wɔ sɛ bere tenten a wɔka saa nneɛma yi na afei wɔka nsɛmfua no, nanso wɔnda nkyerɛase ahorow no adi ankasa, sɛ wobetumi anya wɔn ho afi ho nso. Enti Sam de asɛm a ɛma ɛyɛ te sɛ “Yɛwɔ nkyerɛwde kɔkɔɔ koro no ara pɛpɛɛpɛ sɛnea Anthropic nyae no, na aban no yɛɛ kɛse wɔ saa asɛm no ho.”
Nokwarem no, misusuw sɛ Sam Altman kae sɛ Anthropic wɔ nkyerɛwde kɔkɔɔ abien na OpenAI wɔ abiɛsa, na aban no yɛɛ yiye koraa wɔ ho, na ɛno maa nnipa pii yɛɛ wɔn ti a wɔde twitwiw wɔn tirim. Nanso mesusu sɛ ɛsɛ sɛ ɛyɛ sɛ Sam Altman ne obiara a na watwa ne ho ahyia no ante sɛdeɛ saa nneɛma yi yɛ adwuma wɔ nneyɛeɛ mu ase, anaasɛ wɔte aseɛ, na wɔfaa no ara sɛ ɔmanfoɔ renhunu na ɛno nti wɔbɛtumi anya wɔn ho.
Adeɛ foforɔ a ɛba w’adwene mu — bio, AI yɛ foforɔ na ɛyɛ sɔhwɛ kɛseɛ sɛ wobɛba mfiridwuma foforɔ so sɛdeɛ yeinom yɛ ɔhaw a ɛfa adwene a ɛdi kan ho. “Ɛnsɛ sɛ obiara susuw eyi ho da,” nanso nokwasɛm ne sɛ obiara asusuw saa nneɛma yi ho akyɛ. Ebia ade a ɛyɛ foforo wɔ ha no nyɛ AI, na mmom sɛ Trump nniso a ɛto so abien no, sɛ́ anka wɔbɛyɛ mmaranimfo kuw bi a ebia obiara renkenkan da de bu wɔn nneyɛe no bem wɔ kokoam asennibea bi a obiara mfa n’adwene nsi so no, mmom ɛnyɛ anifere saa ara.
Wɔnnyɛ sophisticated saa na wɔreka kɛkɛ sɛ wɔbɛ spy obiara bere nyinaa. Wɔde wɔn adwene too gua kɛkɛ wɔ ɔkwan bi so a ebia ɛsɛ sɛ administrations nyinaa de wɔn adwene to gua kɛkɛ na wɔhwɛ baabi a chips no hwe ase.
Nanso m’ahwɛ nokwasɛm a ɛyɛ sɛ na Ed Snowden wɔ hɔ wɔ New York City ha. AT&T na ɛhwɛ ɔdan bi a obiara nim sɛ ɛyɛ NSA dan. Ɛyɛ ɔdan kɛse bi kɛkɛ, na ɛsɛ sɛ yɛyɛ yɛn ho sɛ ɛnyɛ NSA beae a wɔhwɛ nneɛma so, nanso ɛwɔ hɔ ara. Ɛyɛ kɛse. Ɛte sɛ nea ɛno mu biara amma biribiara. Saa adiyisɛm yi nyinaa, saa leaks yi, yɛnsan n’akyi.
Nokwarem no, ɛkɔ soro bere a yɛn asetra mu dodow no ara ayɛ dijitaal kɛse no. Na ebia sɛ Trump nniso no yɛ adwinnade a ɛyɛ mmerɛw saa bere nyinaa nti, ebia ɛno ne ade a ɛde akontaabu no ba ankasa. So wuhu sɛ ɛno rekɔ so ɔkwan biara so?
Nneɛma ahorow kakraa bi wɔ hɔ, na ɛnyɛ nokware koraa sɛ yɛansan yɛn akyi koraa wɔ saa nneɛma yi mu. Adiyisɛm a ɛfiri Snowden hɔ no maa nsakraeɛ bi baa sɛdeɛ saa nneɛma yi kɔ so no mu ampa. Na ɛwɔ hɔ seesei — me werɛ fi nea wɔfrɛ wɔn, nanso wɔte sɛ saa civil amicus nnipa yi a wɔwɔ FISA asɛnnibea a wɔbɛyɛ adwuma sɛ wɔde ɔfã foforo no bɛkyerɛ wɔ nsɛm bi ho.
Na yɛahu sɛ atumfoɔ no binom anohyeto wɔ akwan bi so, na wɔba sɛ wɔbɛsan ama tumi krataa mpɛn pii, na adwumayɛfoɔ ayɛ basabasa kɛseɛ wɔ pia a wɔbɛpia wɔn akyi na wɔabɔ mmɔden sɛ wɔde guardrails foforɔ bi bɛhyɛ mu. Nanso asɛmmisa kɛse no ho no, misusuw sɛ nneɛma abien na ɛsono emu biara. You’re half right in that saa administration yi nyɛ subtle na ɛka nneɛma a ɛnsɛ sɛ ɛka no den ara kwa.
"Yɛne Iran reko, yɛreyɛ, ɛrekɔ so. Yɛrensɔ asaw no mpo nhwɛ."
Wɔ akwan horow a anka nniso ahorow a atwam nyinaa rennyɛ so. Nanso wɔanka saa asɛm no tẽẽ ankasa wɔa wɔde hwɛ nneɛma so, titiriw Amerikafo a wɔhwɛ wɔn so. Wɔayɛ hints a ɛfa ho, nanso wɔanpue denneennen saa wɔ saa asɛm no ho. Ne fã a aka no fa Anthropic’s gyinabea ne adwene a ɛwɔ hɔ nyinaa wɔ AI ho sɛ saa mfiridwuma a ebetumi aba sɛ ɛwɔ hɔ yi, faako a Anthropic ada ne ho adi bere nyinaa sɛ, “Yɛyɛ nnipa pa a wosusuw nneɛma ho,” ne sɛ ebia wugye di anaasɛ wunnye nni sɛ ɛno yɛ ɔkwan bi so a ɛka asɛm no ho. Wɔwɔ din yi wɔ hɔ: “Yɛrebɔ mmɔden sɛ yɛbɛyɛ eyi wɔ ɔkwan a ahobammɔ wom so, a ɛkyerɛ obu ma adesamma na ɛreyɛ aso wɔ saa nneɛma yi nyinaa so.” Na enti sɛ wowɔ saa ntɔkwaw no a, ɛhɔ na apereperedi no ba.
Wowɔ Trump nniso bi a wɔpɛ sɛ wotumi yɛ biribiara a wɔpɛ sɛ wotumi yɛ kɛkɛ, na wɔnyɛ anifere wɔ saa asɛm no ho. Na afei wowɔ Anthropic, a ne ho nkyerɛkyerɛmu ne ne baguam nipasu te sɛ, “Yɛdwene nneɛma ho na yɛbu adesamma ne hokwan ne saa nneɛma yi nyinaa.” Ɛbɛyɛ sɛ ɛhɔ na ntawntawdi no bae, efisɛ Anthropic, sɛnea wɔama emu ada hɔ no, ne Defence Department ayɛ adwuma bere tiaa bi na wɔne aban no ayɛ apam afoforo pii a wɔde adi dwuma. Ɛnyɛ ɔhaw biara.
Ɛyɛ mmeae pɔtee yi nkutoo a, bere a na aban no rehwehwɛ sɛ ɛbɛtrɛw apam a na ɔwɔ no mu no, na Anthropic akannifo mpanyimfo no fii ase kae sɛ, “Twɛn, ɛsɛ sɛ yɛhwɛ hu sɛ yɛrentwa nhama kɔkɔɔ yi a ebetumi apira yɛn din sɛ AI a ɔde ma a osusuw nneɛma ho, a ahobammɔ wom no.”
Mepɛ sɛ mibisa mo tiawa fa surveillance ho wɔ ɔkwan a ɛkɔ akyiri so, ne titiriw no Anthropic’s Fourth Amendment haw no ho. Fourth Amendment no se aban no ntumi nhwehwɛ wo mu a ntease nnim. Ɔkwan pa a wobɛfa so ate Nsakrae a Ɛto so Anan no ase ne sɛ wubetie “Ɔhaw 99” a Jay-Z kyerɛwee no. Enti sɛ ɛho hia sɛ wugye w’ahome na wokɔ tie “99 Problems” a, ɛno yɛ fɛ yiye. Ne nyinaa wɔ hɔ. Mitiee no bere a na mewɔ mmara sukuu mu na ntease wom koraa.
Nanso mpɛn pii no aban no hia tumi krataa a wɔde bɛhwehwɛ wo mu. Na bere a w’asetra mu nsɛm pii kɔ Intanɛt so no, nneɛma pii wɔ hɔ a ɛsono eyi. Nanso adwene no ne sɛ ɛsɛ sɛ wɔda so ara hia tumi krataa wɔ intanɛt so. Anthropic’s argument is, "Wiɛ, AI no remmrɛ da. Etumi hwehwɛ biribiara mu bere nyinaa. Ɛno kyerɛ sɛ yɛbɛyɛ master surveillance kɛkɛ."
Nanso ansa na AI reba mpo no, na adwene a ɛne sɛ aban no betumi ahwehwɛ biribiara a ɛyɛ wo dea mu no wɔ abɔnten hɔ, adwene a ɛne sɛ aban no nhia tumi krataa a wɔde bɛhwehwɛ wo nneɛma nyinaa mu no wɔ abɔnten hɔ. Adwene a ɛne sɛ sɛ wo data no bi kɔ ɔman no akyi sekan tiawa bi da bi a, aban no twaa mu wɔ hɔ no, .
Bere a na mewɔ kɔlege, bɛyɛ bere a wɔreyɛ Patriot Act no, na akyinnyegye no ne sɛ wɔrenhwehwɛ wo data ankasa mu, nanso wobetumi anya metadata ne metadata no nkutoo. Data a ɛfa wo data ho no bɛdɔɔso sɛ ɛbɛma woahu baabi a wowɔ pɛpɛɛpɛ bere nyinaa. Na ɛno mpo yɛ akyirikyiri dodo. Na yɛayɛ saa asaw yi a ɛkyerɛ sɛ dɛn na aban no betumi aboaboa ano? Dɛn na wɔma ho kwan? Dɛn na wohia na ama yɛn nyinaa anya ahobammɔ na dɛn na ɛwɔ akyirikyiri dodo? Saa nkyerɛwde no atu akɔ baabi foforo.
Enti ka dadwen a ɛwɔ hɔ nyinaa wɔ surveillance wɔ nsenia no so ne baabi a yɛwɔ mprempren no mu tiawa kɛkɛ. Ansa na AI tebea no rema biribiara ayɛ den kɛse.
Ɛha na ɛsɛ sɛ mede adwene foforo a ebia anka ɛsɛ sɛ yɛdi kan ka ho asɛm, nanso ɛho hia, a wɔfrɛ no “afã abiɛsa nkyerɛkyerɛ” no ba. Adwene a ɛwɔ Nsakraeɛ a Ɛtɔ so Anan no mu ne sɛ aban no ntumi nhwehwɛ wo anaa wo nneɛma mu a enni tumi krataa na ɛrentumi nnya tumi krataa a ɛnyɛ nea ɛbɛtumi aba sɛ woayɛ nsɛmmɔnedi bi. Nanso saa adwene yi wɔ hɔ a ɛbaa bɛyɛ mfe du du a atwam ni a wɔfrɛ no third-party doctrine, a ɛka sɛ ɛno mfata, anaasɛ ɛnyɛ adwuma koraa, wɔ nneɛma a ɛnyɛ wo de ho, sɛ ɛyɛ wo data mpo a.
Eyi mu nea edi kan na ɛda adi kɛse ne telefon so kyerɛwtohɔ ahorow a na telefon adwumakuw no wɔ wɔ onii a wofrɛɛ no ho. Na telefon adwumakuw no nkyere wo frɛ, nanso na wɔrekyere sɛ mefrɛ wo a, anka kyerɛwtohɔ bi bɛba telefon adwumakuw no mu a ɛka sɛ, “Mike frɛ Nilay.” Na nea na asennibea ahorow pii asi gyinae ne sɛ aban no betumi akɔ abisa saa, na wonhia tumi krataa ma ɛno efisɛ ɛnyɛ nhwehwɛmuwo data no, ɛyɛ saa onipa a ɔto so abiɛsa yi na wobetumi apene so sɛ obi a ɔto so abiɛsa sɛ wɔde saa data no bɛma kɛkɛ.
Nanso na ɛnonom yɛ nsɛm a ɛfiri 1960 ne 70 mfeɛ no mu, baabi a wɔsii gyinaeɛ sɛ aban no bɛtumi anya saa kwan no so a ɔnni tumi krataa, berɛ a na nnipa foforɔ data pii nni hɔ saa. Kɔmputa ne intanɛt a ɛkɔɔ soro no sesaa saa asɛm no. Seesei, biribiara yɛ nnipa a wɔto so abiɛsa data. Biribiara a yɛyɛ no, adwumakuw bi na ɛboaboa ano wɔ baabi na yɛwɔ ho kyerɛwtohɔ. Enti titiriw no data biara a ɛfa wo ho, baabi a wowɔ, onii a wo ne no kasa, onii a wo ne no di nkitaho, nea woka, nea woreyɛ, ne nyinaa yɛ nea nnipa a wɔto so abiɛsa kura no mu kɛse nnansa yi. Enti third-party doctrine no amene Fourth Amendment no nyinaa akodu baabi, baabi a biribiara a ɛfa wo ho a obi foforo wɔ no, there’s a much lower standard for what the government can do to request it.
Sɛ yɛbɛka no pɔtee kɛkɛ a, eyi kyerɛ sɛ sɛ me data wɔ iCloud mu a, aban no betumi akɔ Apple na akɔfa me data afi iCloud mu a wɔrenka nkyerɛ me da?
Wobetumi abisa. Ɛnyɛ den sɛ wobetumi abisa a wonni tumi krataa. Afei adwumakuw no wɔ n’ankasa hokwan ahorow na wobetumi akyerɛ nea wɔpɛ sɛ wɔde saa abisade no yɛ. Wobetumi agyae kɛkɛ. Wobetumi, sɛnea wɔn mu dodow no ara bɛyɛ no, sɛ ɛyɛ adesrɛ a anibere wom a, apow abisade ahorow a efi wɔn nsam anaasɛ wobetumi abɔ wo kɔkɔ na wɔatumi aka — na eyi ne nea wɔn mu dodow no ara bɛyɛ — wɔbɛbɔ wo kɔkɔ na wɔaka sɛ, “Aban no rebisa wo data no bi. Wubetumi akɔ asɛnnibea na woabɔ mmɔden sɛ wubesiw wɔn kwan.” Sɛ ɛnte saa a, wɔde wo data bɛma wɔ nnanson anaa nea ɛbɛyɛ biara mu.
Bio nso, egyina so. Sɛ ɛyɛ nsɛmmɔnedi ho nhwehwɛmu a, ɛnde ebia gag order bi wɔ hɔ a adwumakuw no mma kwan sɛ wɔbɛka akyerɛ wo. Tebea ahorow nyinaa wɔ hɔ, nanso emu dodow no ara mfa ahobammɔ a ennu ahobammɔ a Nsakrae a Ɛto so Anan no bɛhwehwɛ sɛ ɛyɛ data anaa nsɛm biara anaa biribiara a ɛwɔ w’ankasa wo fie no ho.
Data dodow a wowɔ wɔ obi foforo cloud server so no yɛ kɛse, ɛnte saa? Adeɛ baako biara a woyɛ no mpɛn pii wɔ intanɛt so seesei no, wɔakora so wɔ ɔkwan bi so anaasɛ wɔakyere agu hama so wɔ ɔkwan bi so wɔ obi foforɔ servers so. Aban no anya saa kwan yi a ɛbɛfa so atwa Nsakrae a Ɛto so Anan no ho ahyia na waka sɛ, “Wiɛ, ɛnyɛ wo de ankasa. Ɛyɛ Amazon dea. Yebetumi akɔ ne Amazon akasa,” na ɛsɛ sɛ Amazon gyina saa nhyehyɛe no mfinimfini na ɛka sɛ, “Yɛayɛ ɔkwan foforo a yɛbɛfa so abɔ nkurɔfo no ho ban kakra.”
Mehwɛ saa —na berɛ a na merekata nnipa mmiɛnsa nkyerɛkyerɛ nsɛm a ɛdi kan a ɛkata mununkum dwumadie so na aban no kɔɔ so dii nkonim no, ɛno ne berɛ a me danee Joker no titire. Na me te sɛ, “Saa nneɛma yi nyinaa a yɛreyɛ yɛn ho sɛ ɛfa nkyerɛwee ne [akenkan] a ɛnyɛ den ho no, eyi mu biara nkyerɛ hwee efisɛ yɛde apɔnkɔ ahoɔden kɛkɛ kɔ akyi pon no so de tete mmara yi di dwuma kɔ obiara data mu.”
Na afei mehwɛ yei na mehwɛ Anthropic na meka sɛ, “Wiɛ, yei yɛ nhwɛsoɔ korɔ no ara.” Eyi yɛ ankorankoro adwumakuw bi a ɛka sɛ, "Okay, yɛte wo gyinabea ase. Yɛte ase sɛ woasan akyerɛ mmara no ase sɛ ɛkyerɛ saa ade yi, na yɛde nhyehyɛe bi bɛhyɛ wo, yɛn adwinnade no, ne Amerikafo data a ɛsen fa yɛn som mu no ntam." Me rebisa kɛkɛ sɛ wobɛhunu saa nsɛsoɔ no wɔ hɔ, wɔ Anthropic ne Amazon ne Azure ne cloud services foforɔ biara a ɛwɔ hɔ a ɛkura yɛn data dodoɔ no ara ntam.
Yeah, ɛwom sɛ nkyerɛkyerɛmu kakraa bi wɔ hɔ a ɛho hia wɔ ha a ɛma eyi yɛ soronko kakra. Na nokwarem no — misusuw sɛ The New York Times nyaa saa amanneɛbɔ yi kan — ɔkasamu titiriw a na ɛho hia kɛse ma Anthropic no fa data a wɔaboaboa ano afi aguadi nnwuma mu ne sɛ wontumi mfa Claude nni dwuma wɔ saa data no so ho titiriw, a ɛyɛ saa asɛm yi pɛpɛɛpɛ wɔ nnipa foforo data ho. Nanso mepɛ sɛ mema nsonsonoe titiriw a ɛda nea na yɛreka ho asɛm ara kwa ansa na eyi reba no mu da hɔ a Amazon anaasɛ nnipa afoforo a wɔto so abiɛsa a wɔregye wo data no, na ɛnonom yɛ nsɛm a na wɔwɔ, esiane baabi a wɔte wɔ ecosystem no mu nti, na wɔregye wo data no tẽẽ.
Claude deɛ, ɛnyɛ sɛ obiara haw sɛ NSA bɛhwɛ wo Claude dwumadie no mu. Ɛfa wɔn a wɔbɛkɔ akɔgye data a ɛfiri Amazon anaasɛ ɛda adi sɛ data brokers a wɔyɛ sum ase, ahintaw a wɔde dawurubɔ ma wɔ wo fon so na wonim wo beaeɛ ne w’anigyedeɛ ne nneɛma a ɛtete saa. Na afei ɛno a wɔde ma wɔ nhyehyɛe bi mua afei Claude bɛyɛ ho adwuma. Ɛno ne nea Anthropic mpɛ sɛ ɔyɛ ne fã ankasa. Enti baabiara anaa ɔkwan biara a aban no bɛboaboa saa data no ano afi obi foforo hɔ no, Anthropic kae sɛ, “Yɛmpɛ sɛ wɔde yɛn adwinnade no bedi dwuma wɔ saa data no so.”
Apple agye din sɛ egyina FBI anim sɛ wɔmfa akyi pon nhyɛ iPhone no mu, na Apple ka sɛ “dabi,” na wogyina Trump anim. Na sɛnea yɛn nhyehyɛe no yɛ adwuma no fã bi wɔ hɔ a ankorankoro nnwumakuw akɛse nya kwan ka sɛ “dabi” kyerɛ aban no wɔ wɔn adetɔfo ananmu. Na eyi tee nka wɔ ɔkwan koro no ara so sɛ Apple, bio, remfa nhyɛ akyi pon wɔ iPhone no so, anaasɛ mununkum akɛse a wɔde ma no ka sɛ, “Akwan bi wɔ hɔ kakra a ɛsɛ sɛ wuhuruw fa mu ansa na woanya ankorankoro data no.”
Ɛha no ɛte sɛ nea Anthropic reka sɛ, “Ɛnyɛ sɛ yɛrenyɛ data a woanya afi akuw afoforo hɔ no mu nhwehwɛmu a ɛdɔɔso kɛkɛ efisɛ ɛno ma wɔhwɛ Amerikafo pii so 24/7, na yɛmpɛ sɛ yɛyɛ saa.” Nanso ɛte sɛ nea ɛno yɛ abɔntenban a ɛkɔ akyiri dodo ma saa nniso yi. So biribi wɔ hɔ a ɛbɛsan aba afi ɛno mu?
Yɛbɛhwɛ. Wɔ bere a atwam no mu bere a ɛno sii — na ɛbaa mpɛn pii wɔ tech nnwumakuw akɛse dodow no ara ho no, wɔ bere bi mu no wɔaka sɛ biribi yɛ bridge a ɛkɔ akyiri dodo — baabi a ɛno taa kɔ ne asɛnnibea. Nnwumakuw no bɛkɔ asɛnnibea anaasɛ administration no bɛkɔ asɛnnibea na there’ll be some sort of court battle.
Akyi pon a ɛkɔ iPhone no mu no yɛ ɛno ho nhwɛso a edi mũ. Ɛkɔɔ asɛnnibea na wɔko tiaa no, ɛwom sɛ wɔantumi ankɔ awiei koraa da efisɛ awiei koraa no FBI no de nsa bubuu iPhone no mu kɛkɛ na afei wɔmpɛ sɛ asɛnnibea gyinaesi no bɛsɛe saa daakye.
Nanso wɔ saa asɛm yi mu no, baabi a nkɔanim no wɔ ne baabi a eyi yɛ soronko wɔ saa tebea horow a atwam no ho ne sɛ sɛ́ anka wɔbɛkɔ asɛnnibea kɛkɛ no, Trump nniso no yɛɛ saa “supply-chain risk” din yi, a ɛyɛ nkwaseasɛm ara kwa. Saa adwene yi sɛ saa adwinnade yi a wɔyɛɛ no sɛ wɔde besiw amannɔnefo a wobetumi ayɛ adebɔneyɛfo kwan sɛ wɔde mfiridwuma bɛma, a afei ebetumi de nnwinnade a wɔde hwɛ nneɛma so a ahintaw ahyɛ mfiridwuma a wɔaboaboa ano kɛse no mu no, sɛ wobetumi abara wɔn. Sɛ wɔde saa asɛm no bedi dwuma wɔ adwumakuw bi a ɛwɔ U.S. ho titiriw esiane sɛ wɔwɔ abrabɔ pa ho nhyehyɛe nti a, ɛte sɛ nea wɔde saa adwinnade no adi dwuma ɔkwammɔne so ankasa, ankasa.
Na saa adwinnade no mpo yɛ nea asɛm wɔ ho wɔ akwan bi so, nanso wubetumi ate nkannyan a ɛwɔ akyi no ase bere a woreka Chinafo adwumakuw bi a wɔyɛ nkitahodi nhyehyɛe anaa biribi a ɛte saa ho asɛm no. Ɛha yi, ntease biara nni mu. Enti sɛnea wɔyɛ wɔn ade wɔ eyi ho no boro nea anka wobehu wɔ asɛm yi mu no so koraa. Wubetumi ahu atetesɛm mu no, asɛnnibea asɛm bi bɛba na ɔfã biara betumi afi ase na ɛbɛyɛ ɔko ara kwa wɔ sɛnea wobetumi de apam no adi dwuma ho.
Nanso ɛnyɛ saa na ɛrekɔ so wɔ ha. Saa aban yi reka wɔ ɔkwan a etu mpɔn so sɛ, “Sɛ woamma yɛn biribiara a yɛpɛ koraa, sɛ woamfa wo nnwinnade no ansiesie sɛnea yɛpɛ sɛ ɛyɛ adwuma a, ɛnde yɛbɛbɔ mmɔden wɔ ɔkwan a etu mpɔn so sɛ yɛbɛsɛe w’adwuma no nyinaa.” Na ɛno yɛ nkɔanim a ɛkɔ soro.
Eyi mu baako wɔ hɔ a mepɛ sɛ mewie wɔ so, na ɛyɛ galaxy-brain version a ɛsen biara wɔ eyi mu. FIRE, a ɛyɛ kasa mu ahofadi kuw bi, de blog post bi too hɔ ansa na yɛrefi ase akyere agu hama so de akyinnyegye a ɛne sɛ sɛ wɔhyɛ Anthropic ma wɔnyɛ nnwinnade a wɔmpɛ sɛ wɔyɛ no yɛ kasa mu ahofadi a wɔabu so, sɛ ɛyɛ biribi a wɔfrɛ no kasa a wɔhyɛ. Abakɔsɛm pii wɔ ha. Verge ne Techdirt, in-the-weeds, existential-crisis abakɔsɛm bi a emu dɔ wɔ ha.
Nanso ne titire no ɛba fam wɔ adwene a ɛne sɛ mmara yɛ kasa, sɛ mmara a wɔkyerɛw ma kɔmputa yɛ kasa bi na aban no ntumi nhyɛ wo sɛ wonyɛ, na nneɛma pii sen fi saa. So wotɔ saa akyinnyegye yi sɛ sɛ wɔhyɛ Anthropic ma wɔnyɛ nnwinnade a wɔmpɛ sɛ wɔyɛ no yɛ kasa a wɔhyɛ?
Yeah, nokwarem no misusuw sɛ ɛyɛ nea ɛhyɛ nkuran yiye. Ɔkasa a wɔhyɛ a ɛhyɛ nkuran. Nanso dabi, misusuw sɛ ɛyɛ akyinnyegye a ɛyɛ anigye. Ɛyɛ biako a na akɔ akyiri kakra wɔ nsɛm a na meredwen ho no din mu. Ɛda adi sɛ na mede m’adwene asi Nsakrae a Ɛto so Anan no nsɛm so kɛse, nanso misusuw sɛ OGYA ho akyinnyegye no nyɛ mfomso. Yɛahu eyi wɔ nsɛm afoforo mu. Ɛbaa akyi apon ho asɛm no nso mu ampa, wɔ mmɔden a wɔbɔ sɛ wɔbɛkyekyere akyi apon ayɛ no nhyehyɛe ahorow a wɔabɔ no kokoam no ho.
Akyinnye biara nni ho sɛ nnwumakuw a wɔtetee FirstNsakrae no ka sɛ, “Ɛyɛ kasa a wɔhyɛ sɛ ɛhyɛ yɛn ma yɛkyerɛw saa mmara no.” Ɛyɛ akyinnyegye a ɛfata. Ebia ɛbɛyɛ, bio, nea ebia asennibea ahorow nni ɔpɛ kɛse sɛ wobedi ho dwuma mfiase no sɛ wobetumi adi nsɛm yi ho dwuma ɔkwan foforo so a. Nanso m’ani agye sɛ FIRE yɛɛ saa post no na mesusu sɛ ɛyɛ akyinnyegyeɛ a ɛyɛ anigyeɛ na ɛhyɛ nkuran.
Yeah, ɛyɛ Trump nniso a ɛtɔ so mmienu no su ara kwa ne sɛ ɛyɛ adwinnadeɛ a ɛyɛ blunt saa, ɛkame ayɛ sɛ ɛyɛ awerɛhyɛmu sɛ yɛbɛtow ahyɛ nsɛm no nyinaa so prɛko pɛ.
Yiw, ɛsɛ sɛ wɔde asɛm biara a ebetumi aba no kasa tia Hokwan Ho Mmara mu nsakrae biara wɔ ɔkwan bi so.
[Ɔserew] Twitwa ntwahonan no.
I’m sure yɛbɛtumi afa Third Amendment violation wɔ baabi wɔ ha.
Ampa, yeah. Ɛsɛ sɛ Claude te wo fie mprempren. Pɛpɛɛpɛ. Ɛbɛyɛ kɛse. Yɛreyɛ [nsakraeɛ] baako, mmiɛnsa, anan, ne nson. Yɛ rack ’em up.
Mike, eyi ayɛ kɛse. Minnye nni sɛ woankɔ ɔyɛkyerɛ no mu da. Eyi ayɛ kɛse. Ɛsɛ sɛ wosan ba ntɛm.
Pɛpɛɛpɛ. Bere biara a wopɛ me.
Nsɛmmisa anaa nsɛm a wɔka fa saa adeyɛ yi ho? Hit yɛn wɔ decoder@theverge.com. Yɛkenkan email biara ampa!
